Even Better Than the Last Thing

Since Barack Obama and Mitt Romney last met, the electoral world has changed.  Two weeks ago I (and many others) was ready to proclaim that the Republican campaign was effectively over, and that there was just about no way they could possibly win.

What a difference one debate made.  At least according to the conventional wisdom.  Take a look at this chart, and you’ll see the dramatic shift:The Romney campaign seems resurrected from the dead, and every day new articles talk about the great shift that has occurred.

To be sure, things are a lot closer than they were and the race has tightened.  Yet even in this tightening it isn’t as if Romney has moved into a commanding lead–simply a position of parity with the Democratic ticket.  Furthermore, two other charts from RealClearPolitics reveal that, based on the current polls, Romney is not in the lead in electoral votes, which is of course the only kind of math that really matters.

In one sense, this electoral vote contest is close as well.  Take for instance, this chart, which highlights those states that seem likely to go to one candidate or the other:Remember, of course, that while the votes are pretty close, Romney does lag behind; not all of the toss ups are as equally available to him as others.  Going deeper, if we were to follow the direction indicated by a number of polls to further predict the results of the election (definitively assigning electoral votes to one or the other depending on who leads in state polls right now), here are the results:This map even gives Mitt Romney the big state of Florida, and still he cannot reach the magic number of 270 electoral votes.  Even if he manages to take Ohio (an almost must-win state for him and one where is not leading right now), that only takes him to 262.

Is it possible for Mitt Romney to scrap together the necessary electoral votes?  Absolutely.  Is it still harder for him to do than President Obama?  I think so.  Mark Halperin suggested last night that there is a reasonable scenario that has Romney winning, but all still rests on Ohio–a state that he has not really led in.

All of this  is to say, of course, that tonight’s debate is vital for Mitt Romney.  President Obama will almost assuredly not give the lackluster performance he did last time, and in this kind of contest a tie would very well go to the defender.  A tie would serve, perhaps, to stabilize the changes in this race and retain the status quo.  If things stay the same Mitt Romney still has ground to make up, and any shift of momentum back in the other direction means that Romney, who is not really winning right now, will be even farther away from his goal.

Because of the modified expectations for the candidates after the last debate, it will be incredibly hard for Governor Romney to emerge as the clear winner, yet only if he does can the energy of this campaign firmly be said to have shifted in his corner.  In other words, if he wins tonight, the contest will be about Obama trying to beat Romney instead of the other way around.

If he wins…which I think is a very, very tall order indeed.


4 comments on “Even Better Than the Last Thing

  1. Nate says:

    Josh, what about the idea that the polls aren’t really indicative of the actual election because is is assuming Democratic participation on 2008 levels. Many have jumped off the “Hope and Change” bandwagon, and the level of enthusiasm is pretty low for Dems. It seems that Republicans are more motivated to vote this time around.

    • Joshua R. Ziefle says:

      Maybe; I not sure of the apparatus utilized here in the poll creation. Even so, The fact that Romney continues to lag, even a little, in these aggregate polls (and for instance, just about all of the polls in Ohio) makes me think things are not super rosy for him.

  2. crgardenjoe says:

    Interesting analysis–all the more so for the Real Clear Politics charts. Don’t you just love that site? I think the enthusiasm gap is tightening a bit, at least in my swing state of Iowa–both Dems and GOP sense possiblity and the final push for both will be strong …

  3. […] awake, realizing that despite Obama’s impressive lead in Electoral College votes, see this fine blog post, it could still all slip away.  Obama volunteers have been practically having a party on my front […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s