Churchless Church

tumblr_lu1w4jKqxj1r07zq0A few weeks ago I was in Southern California for a “church tour.”  Together with a few professors and about 20 ministry students, I visited nine church services in a weekend.  It was a bit of a marathon, but I survived.

The goal for the students was to gain an appreciation for the way “church” was done in a few different contexts, make observations that might serve to benefit their future ministries, and analyze a variety of sermons.

My experience of the weekend was similarly organized, but at some point it also turned a bit pessimistic.  Observing so many church services in one weekend, while supposedly meant to be an “uplifting” experience, actually caused me to wonder why in the world we do all of the things in we feel that we have to do.  If Christianity is a matter of the spirit, both individually and as gathered with others in communion with Christ, then why does so much of “church” feel so…artificial?  Strange songs, standing and sitting, listening to someone talk for an hour, varying dress codes, Christian clichés.  Even that portion where we’re all forced to shake each others’ hands.  Really?  What is it all theholydepotabout?  It is an interesting question.

Some of our discomfort with the “strangeness” with church life might simply have to do with the “strangeness” or other-ness of God.  This I accept wholeheartedly.  God’s ways are not our ways, and as a good Pentecostal I recognize that the presence of the Almighty can manifest itself in diverse and unexpected ways.

Some of the reason that church services seem artificial might simply be because our world can tend to be rather secularized, or antagonistic to such organized religious faith.  Because we live in a world that doesn’t like to talk about or reflect upon religious faith, places where we do so naturally feel weird.

All the same, neither of these two things really get at some of the ways in which church as “church” can become rather a thing unto itself.  An institution not serving the world or its Lord, but rather itself.

Now, don’t get me wrong.  I’m not one of these “Jesus hates the Church/religion” people.  I think that’s a little overblown.  As it is the Body of Christ, I love and cherish the Church Universal throughout all space and time.  Yes, Christianity is about relationship, but as relationship is organized it naturally takes form and structure.  When it comes to human relations with God, that structure is called religion.  That’s simply the way it is.  But I’ll tell you what…I do think that some of the ways we act and organize ourselves when we as the gathered community join together for church services can be strange (at best).

Ultimately, I believe we keep doing things in certain ways because a) we think we have to by the bonds of tradition or sometimes misunderstood Scripture, b) we’re not creative enough to think of any other way, and c) we are more comfortable with it than we are changing.  I’m not sure that any of these is sufficient reason to keep doing what we’re doing.  If the goal in all of this is a matter of the Spirit, in our predictable churchy ways I’m not sure we’re following where the Spirit’s blowing.

hs_bonhoeffer_dietrich_-copy1I’ve been vague about which practices, habits, and forms I’m critiquing here.  Perhaps intentionally so.  I think that all of us, if we think about it, could come up with ways in which our churches and local congregations are focused so much on peculiar side-quests and the maintenance of non-essential and (from an outside point of view) bizarre practices we don’t even realize that we’re propping up what amounts to nothing but our own preferences or lethargic momentum writ large.

It is times like this that I think about Dietrich Bonhoeffer and his thoughts about “religionless Christianity.”  His use of the term is debated, so I’ll just quote him:

Our whole nineteen-hundred-year-old Christian preaching and theology rest on the “religious a priori” of mankind. “Christianity” has always been a form–perhaps the true form–of “religion.” But if one day it becomes clear that this a priori does not exist at all, but was a historically conditioned and transient form of human self-expression, and if therefore man becomes radically religionless–and I think that that is already more or less the case…what does that mean for “Christianity”? It means that the foundation is taken away from the whole of what has up to now been our “Christianity,” and that there remain only a few “last survivors of the age of chivalry,” or a few intellectually dishonest people that we are to pounce in fervor, pique, or indignation, in order to sell them goods? Are we to fall upon a few unfortunate people in their hour of need and exercise a sort of religious compulsion on them?

If we don’t want to do all that, if our final judgment must be that the Western form of Christianity, too, was only a preliminary stage to a complete absence of religion, what kind of situation emerges for us, for the church? How can Christ become the Lord of the religionless as well? Are there religionless Christians? If religion is only a garment of Christianity–and even this garment has looked very different at different times–then what is a religionless Christianity?


5 comments on “Churchless Church

  1. Anna says:

    Firstly, I think you are right, that our worship rituals and traditions are often strange and, well, tradition bound in ways that are not helpful to proclaiming the gospel. But within the context of a “worship tour,” such as you were part of, you were stepping into a variety of worshiping communities. Worship is always contextual, and the specific community discerns which practices support the faith of the community. They are strange, if you are a visitor to the community. Worship is something different than the world, and I wouldn’t expect it to feel comfortable or familiar in a different church. I’d hope for enough familiar things that I would know I’m still among fellow Christians – for me that would be scripture, singing of some kind (usually), praying, and eucharist.

    Secondly, what a loss to the world that DB did not live to expand more upon these thoughts. Sometimes I wonder if he were to find himself in our time, if he would consider himself “emergent” or “evangelical catholic” or something else altogether. For my part, I think Bonhoeffer meant less Christianity with “religion,” but Christianity unbound from European cultural and historical baggage.

    • Anna,

      I see what you are saying here, and agree to a large extent. I have likely not articulated myself very well.

      This “church tour” was for the most part a selection of Pentecostal/Charismatic/Evangelical churches of whose genre I am familiar. Perhaps over familiar. Maybe so much of all of that in one weekend underscored the fact that we can just keep doing the same things that can feel rather trite. I’m not talking about deep historic traditions…but American Christianisms. Things that are not, I think, worship….but unnecessary window-dressing. Aesthetic (but not aesthetically pleasing) adiophora.

      What is this “thing,” church, that we have built and are building? Why do I need ushers guiding me to a seat? Why do I need glossy handouts? Why do I need churchy catchphrases?

      It has been a long day, and I’m still probably not articulately myself that well.

      Yeah, this “religionless Christianity” idea is one of the great unanswereds of theology…definitely a lot of room for thought.

  2. Andy Wong says:

    Being an RPG fan, I like the image of side-quests. I have also wondered (and am working on experimenting with) a lot of these questions and in particular “Why is Sunday morning worship the focal event in the lift of the Christian community?” In many contexts, I could go even further and say it’s the defining event for participation (i.e. Regardless of what else you do, if you go, you’re in. If you don’t go, you’re out.)

    • Anna says:

      Andy, worship is the primary place of our theological formation and vocational formation. It is the training ground for Christian life. And it is, of course, the place of Word and Sacrament. “Good” worship is the foundation for all other aspects of our lives. In my mind, “good” means it conveys truths about God, enacts grace, allows people to enter into a sense of holy mystery, brings about the forgiveness of sins, lifts the needs if the world before God, and sends everyone out by the power of the Holy Spirit to be the body of Christ in the world.

  3. Andy Wong says:

    Umm…that was supposed to be “life” of Christian community.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s